‘Boneless’ chicken wings can have bones, US court rules

‘Boneless’ chicken wings can have bones, US court rules Getty Images Boneless chicken wings do not have to be bone-free, Ohio’s top court ruled, ending a lawsuit filed by a man who fell ill after swallowing a piece of bone from his order. Michael Berkheimer sued Wings on Brookwood in 2016, saying the restaurant failed
‘Boneless’ chicken wings can have bones, US court rules

‘Boneless’ chicken wings can have bones, US court rules

Getty Images A plate of boneless chicken wingsGetty Images

Boneless chicken wings do not have to be bone-free, Ohio’s top court ruled, ending a lawsuit filed by a man who fell ill after swallowing a piece of bone from his order.

Michael Berkheimer sued Wings on Brookwood in 2016, saying the restaurant failed to warn him that the boneless wings could in fact contain bones, a piece of which became lodged in his throat and caused an infection.

The court on Thursday ruled that “boneless wing” refers to “cooking style” and is not to be taken literally.

The 4-3 ruling was peppered with dissent, with one judge calling the majority opinion “utter jabberwocky”.

But a majority of the judges considered being cautious of bones in a boneless wing to be common sense.

Writing for the majority, Justice Joseph T Deters said: “A diner reading ‘boneless wings’ on a menu would no more believe that the restaurant was warranting the absence of bones in the items than believe that the items were made from chicken wings, just as a person eating ‘chicken fingers’ would know that he had not been served fingers.”

The chicken wing controversy began in 2016, when Michael Berkheimer was dining with his wife and friends at a restaurant in Hamilton, Ohio.

He ordered what has been described as his “usual” – boneless wings with parmesan garlic sauce – when he noticed a piece go down uncomfortably.

Three days later, he began to feel feverish and went to the emergency room. Doctors discovered a long, thin bone that caused a tear in his oesophagus and a subsequent infection.

Mr Berkheimer later sued the restaurant, accusing them of failing to warn him that the “boneless wings” might contain bones.

In the lawsuit, he also accused the supplier and the farm that produced the chicken of negligence.

Lower courts had dismissed Mr Berkheimer’s suit, which then landed in the state’s supreme court.

A majority of the justices considered it common knowledge that chickens have bones, and sided with the lower courts against him.

“The food item’s label on the menu described a cooking style; it was not a guarantee,” Justice Deters wrote.

However, the dissenting justices felt like the decision should have sat with a jury and not with the court’s justices.

Justice Michael P Donnelly wrote in dissent: “The question must be asked: Does anyone really believe that the parents in this country who feed their young children boneless wings or chicken tenders or chicken nuggets or chicken fingers expect bones to be in the chicken? Of course they don’t.

“When they read the word ‘boneless,’ they think that it means ‘without bones,’ as do all sensible people.”

Total
0
Shares
Leave a Reply
Related Posts
Witt vs. Elly: Battle of the superstar shortstops in CincyWitt vs. Elly: Battle of the superstar shortstops in Cincy
Read More

Witt vs. Elly: Battle of the superstar shortstops in CincyWitt vs. Elly: Battle of the superstar shortstops in Cincy

Witt vs. Elly: Battle of the superstar shortstops in Cincy How young MVP candidates stack up entering big weekend matchup 4:12 AM UTC Sarah Langs @SlangsOnSports Share share-square-690542 Baseball is rife with exciting young talent these days. Two prime examples of that will face off this weekend in Cincinnati. Bobby Witt Jr. has put together
Brits in Lebanon told to ‘leave NOW’ as crisis in the Middle East threatens to ‘deteriorate rapidly’, foreign secretary warns – with UK military scrambled to aid in evacuation of British nationals
Read More

Brits in Lebanon told to ‘leave NOW’ as crisis in the Middle East threatens to ‘deteriorate rapidly’, foreign secretary warns – with UK military scrambled to aid in evacuation of British nationals

British nationals in Lebanon have been told to 'leave now' amid heightened tensions between Israel and Hezbollah, as ministers warn the 'situation could deteriorate rapidly'. Armed forces personnel are heading to the region to support embassies helping UK citizens, while Border Force has sent officers to aid consular operations, the Foreign Office said. Meanwhile, consular experts