First legal challenges to Hochul’s NYC congestion pricing pause set to be filed Thursday

Powerful congestion pricing supporters plan to sue Gov. Kathy Hochul over her 11th-hour pause of the first-in-the-nation tolls, according to two lawsuit drafts obtained by The Post Wednesday. The two lawsuits — which sources said will be filed Thursday in Manhattan Supreme Court — will mark the first legal challenges to Hochul’s decision that scrapped

Powerful congestion pricing supporters plan to sue Gov. Kathy Hochul over her 11th-hour pause of the first-in-the-nation tolls, according to two lawsuit drafts obtained by The Post Wednesday.

The two lawsuits — which sources said will be filed Thursday in Manhattan Supreme Court — will mark the first legal challenges to Hochul’s decision that scrapped the plans just days before $15 tolls were to be imposed on drivers entering Manhattan south of 60th Street.

One suit will be filed by the Riders Alliance and Sierra Club, while The City Club of New York will pursue the other, the drafts show.

Both lawsuits by the nonprofits contend Hochul broke the law when she unilaterally announced the indefinite pause in June.

“As powerful as a governor is, this Governor has no legal authority—none—to ‘direct’ the MTA to ‘pause’ the (Central Business District Tolling Program), much less to directly use her powers as the State’s chief executive to do so,” the City Club lawsuit states.

Gov. Kathy Hochul faces the first legal challenges to her “pause” of congestion pricing. James Messerschmidt

The state law enacting congestion pricing in 2019 exclusively gave power over congestion pricing to a sister agency to the MTA, according to the lawsuit.

“The Governor has no say in the matter. That is the law,” the draft states.

The Riders Alliance and Sierra Club suit contends Hochul also violated the state’s climate change law and constitution by depriving New Yorkers of their right to breathe clean air — a goal congestion pricing aimed to accomplish by reducing traffic in Manhattan.

Other plaintiffs could join the lawsuits, as the complaints obtained by The Post are in draft form.

Hochul paused congestion pricing days before $15 tolls were set to take effect. Christopher Sadowski
The expected lawsuits contend Hochul broke the law when she unilaterally halted congestion pricing. Robert Miller

Comptroller Brad Lander is scheduled to announce a “significant legal development” Thursday morning, possibly tied to the suits.

The lefty Lander, who is eyeing a mayoral run, held a news conference in June with the Riders Alliance and a coalition of congestion pricing supporters that revealed the outlines of potential legal challenges.

“This sudden and potentially illegal reversal wronged a host of New Yorkers, who have a right to what was long promised to all of New York—a world-class mass transit system that works for all,” he said at the time.

“This broad coalition of legal experts and potential plaintiffs will act to ensure the swift and inevitable implementation of congestion pricing—even if it means taking their cases to court.”

Total
0
Shares
Leave a Reply
Related Posts
Map Shows Where Senate Democrats Are Winning in Polls
Read More

Map Shows Where Senate Democrats Are Winning in Polls

With four months until the election, Democrats are leading most Senate polls in competitive states as they face a potentially challenging map that will force them to defend seats in Republican-leaning states. Control of the Senate is up for grabs in November, as both Democrats and Republicans are optimistic about their chances of winning key
Lawyer for Boeing whistleblower claims bosses gave worker ‘PTSD’ and ordered him to ignore 787 defects before killing himself
Read More

Lawyer for Boeing whistleblower claims bosses gave worker ‘PTSD’ and ordered him to ignore 787 defects before killing himself

The Boeing whistleblower who killed himself earlier this year was so distressed by working conditions at its South Carolina plant that he suffered PTSD, his lawyer has claimed. John Barnett, 62, was so troubled by the work environment, his attorney Brian Knowles said, he ended up taking his own life during a legal battle with the carrier