Judge strikes down Biden admin ban on noncompete agreements: ‘Arbitrary and capricious’

 A federal judge in Texas on Tuesday barred a Federal Trade Commission rule from taking effect that would ban agreements commonly signed by workers not to join their employers’ rivals or launch competing businesses. US District Judge Ada Brown in Dallas said the FTC, which enforces federal antitrust laws, does not have the authority to ban

 A federal judge in Texas on Tuesday barred a Federal Trade Commission rule from taking effect that would ban agreements commonly signed by workers not to join their employers’ rivals or launch competing businesses.

US District Judge Ada Brown in Dallas said the FTC, which enforces federal antitrust laws, does not have the authority to ban practices it deems unfair methods of competition by adopting broad rules.

Brown had  temporarily blocked the rule in July while she considered a bid by the US Chamber of Commerce, the country’s largest business lobby, and tax service firm Ryan to strike it down entirely. The rule was set to take effect Sept. 4.

The judge barred a rule from taking effect that would ban agreements commonly signed by workers not to join their employers’ rivals or launch competing businesses. Getty Images

Brown in her ruling said that even if the FTC had the power to adopt the rule, the agency had not justified banning virtually all noncompete agreements.

“The Commission’s lack of evidence as to why they chose to impose such a sweeping prohibition … instead of targeting specific, harmful non-competes, renders the Rule arbitrary and capricious,” wrote Brown, an appointee of Republican former President Donald Trump.

FTC spokesperson Victoria Graham said the agency was disappointed with the ruling and is “seriously considering a potential appeal.”

“Today’s decision does not prevent the FTC from addressing noncompetes through case-by-base enforcement actions,” Graham said in a statement.

The Chamber of Commerce did not immediately respond to a request for comment.

The noncompete ban was set to take effect Sept. 4. Above, President Biden in 2022 speaks at a session of the CEO Summit of the Americas hosted by the US Chamber of Commerce. Getty Images

The Democratic-controlled FTC approved the ban on noncompete agreements in a 3-2 vote in May. The commission and supporters of the rule say the agreements are an unfair restraint on competition that violate US antitrust law and suppress workers’ wages and mobility.

About 30 million people, or 20% of US workers, have signed noncompetes, according to the FTC.

The commission often adopts rules that target specific industries, such as requiring telemarketers to make certain disclosures or mandating that gas stations display fuel ratings, but it is unusual for the agency to enact bans on more widespread business practices.

The Democratic-controlled FTC approved the ban on noncompete agreements in a 3-2 vote in May. AP

Business groups  have argued that Congress never intended to give the FTC those broad powers, and that banning noncompetes will make it difficult to safeguard trade secrets and other confidential information.

Last week, a federal judge in Florida ruled that the ban was likely invalid and blocked it from being applied to a real estate developer. But a judge in Philadelphia went the other way in July, finding that the FTC reasonably concluded that noncompetes are virtually never justified.

Total
0
Shares
Leave a Reply
Related Posts
Every team’s biggest pending free agent for 2024-25Every team’s biggest pending free agent for 2024-25
Read More

Every team’s biggest pending free agent for 2024-25Every team’s biggest pending free agent for 2024-25

Every team’s biggest pending free agent for 2024-25 33 minutes ago Will Leitch @williamfleitch Share share-square-7390 With the Trade Deadline behind us, many pending free agents have found themselves on new teams, as “rental players” for the stretch run. Others remained where they were, potentially for one last march toward the postseason. Either way, though
Cocaine-fuelled driver, 19, who mowed down and killed schoolboy, 13, has his ‘absolutely disgusting’ and ‘insulting’ jail sentence increased after outraged plea by victim’s heartbroken parents
Read More

Cocaine-fuelled driver, 19, who mowed down and killed schoolboy, 13, has his ‘absolutely disgusting’ and ‘insulting’ jail sentence increased after outraged plea by victim’s heartbroken parents

A cocaine-fuelled driver who mowed down and killed a 13-year-old boy has had his 'insulting' jail sentence increased after a plea by the victim's heartbroken parents. Harley Whiteman, 19, downed pints and snorted cocaine before he mowed down schoolboy Kaylan Hippsley on February 29 - and then tried to stop medics from saving his life.   He
Injuries & Moves: Kershaw activated for season debut; Ramírez DFA’dInjuries & Moves: Kershaw activated for season debut; Ramírez DFA’d
Read More

Injuries & Moves: Kershaw activated for season debut; Ramírez DFA’dInjuries & Moves: Kershaw activated for season debut; Ramírez DFA’d

Injuries & Moves: Kershaw activated for season debut; Ramírez DFA'd 6:20 PM UTC MLB.com Share share-square-204096 LATEST NEWS July 25: LHP Clayton Kershaw activated from injured list; RHP Yohan Ramírez designated for assignment Kershaw begins his 17th season after missing 103 games while recovering from offseason shoulder surgery. The three-time Cy Young Award winner struck