NYC official reveals plunging math scores at schools using new DOE curriculum: ‘Decline across the city’

Scores on Algebra 1 Regents exam plummeted by 14 percentage points at south Queens schools that used a controversial new curriculum teachers have blasted as “a complete disaster,” a superintendent revealed this week Josephine Van Ess, superintendent of Queens South High Schools, told parent leaders Wednesday that the 29 high schools under her watch, all

Scores on Algebra 1 Regents exam plummeted by 14 percentage points at south Queens schools that used a controversial new curriculum teachers have blasted as “a complete disaster,” a superintendent revealed this week

Josephine Van Ess, superintendent of Queens South High Schools, told parent leaders Wednesday that the 29 high schools under her watch, all but one of which used the Illustrative Mathematics curriculum, saw their average pass rate plunge from 59% to 45%.

The commercial curriculum — which forces teachers to give scripted lessons on a rigid schedule, expects students to “discover” solutions with little instruction, and frustrates kids lacking prerequisite skills — is partly to blame.

Queens South HS superintendent Josephine Van Ess, above, reported a steep drop in scores on the Algebra 1 Regents exam after schools piloted the Illustrative Math curriculum. Obtained by The New York Post

“Explicit instruction required more training prior to roll out,” said a report Van Ess gave the Citywide Council on High Schools, a parent advisory group. She commented, “I think teachers struggle with the pacing.”

Also challenging is “the level of students being able to talk about math, the conceptual learning that comes with this curriculum,” she said.

And coaching by outside consultants hired by the Department of Education was “limited,” the report said.

The poor performance by her schools — located in the Rockaways, Forest Hills, Jamaica, Richmond Hill, Briarwood, Kew Gardens and South Ozone Park — was not an outlier.

“We saw a decline across the city,” Van Ess said.

Chancellor David Banks has mandated that all but six or seven of NYC’s 420 high schools adopt the commercial curriculum Illustrative Math. Michael Nigro

Her report was the first official disclosure of NYC student performance on the June 4 Regents exams. The city DOE, which scored the exams, has yet to release the citywide results.

The south Queens students did better than last year on nine other state Regents exams, including Algebra 2 — which doesn’t use Illustrative Math; 62% of students who took that exam passed it, up from 50% last year, Van Ess reported. 

The Queens South HS report cited declining scores on the Algebra 1 and Living Environment Regents exams. Obtained by The New York Post

Her schools were among 265 citywide that piloted Illustrative Math, which Chancellor David Banks has mandated that nearly all 420 city high schools adopt in the fall. Only six or seven top-tier, specialized schools will be exempt.

Besides Queens, students from more than 25 schools in three Bronx districts, including some that used Illustrative Math, scored an average failing score of 56.5 on the Algebra 1 exam, The Post learned. That fell below last year’s Bronx borough average of 61. The minimum passing score is 65.

“It’s bad that the results are down,” CCHS president Deborah Kross told The Post after Van Ess gave her report. “It’s not just a little – it’s significant. There’s something wrong.”

In a “root cause analysis” of the failing Algebra 1 scores, Van Ess cited several factors besides the new curriculum.

She noted a 30% jump in the number of  English language learners — which include migrants — and a 5% increase in the number of students with disabilities.

The Algebra 1 exam was different– “more conceptual with less dependency on the calculator,” the analysis said.

In addition, the state set higher “cut scores:” Students had to get 29 of 82 items correct, or 35%, to earn a scaled 65 score. Last year, students needed 27 of 86 points, or 31%, to pass.

Superintendent Van Ess presented a “root cause analysis” with factors behind the plunging Algebra 1 scores. Obtained by The New York Post

Van Ess told the parents she doesn’t yet want to dump the new curriculum — a key component of the DOE’s “New York Solves,” a math initiative expected to cost $34 million over five years.

“With time, more training and understanding, and really being able to fill the gaps with what students need to be successful, I think we can see success,” she said.

Kross, the CCHS president, is doubtful.

“What bothers me is there’s only one year of results in a pilot and it doesn’t look good,’ she said. “Instead of pausing and analyzing what doesn’t work, we’re going to double down.”

DOE spokesman Nathaniel Styer refused to comment on the Algebra scores, but said the Illustrative Math mandate stands: “There has been no change in policy.”

Total
0
Shares
Leave a Reply
Related Posts
Republicans say Schumer must act on voter proof of citizenship bill if Democrat ‘really cares about democracy’
Read More

Republicans say Schumer must act on voter proof of citizenship bill if Democrat ‘really cares about democracy’

close Video Republicans call on Schumer to take action on bill that would require proof of citizenship to vote Reps. Claudia Tenney and Anthony D’Esposito, both from New York, and Alabama Secretary of State Wes Allen spoke to Fox News Digital at the Republican National Convention about the Safeguard American Voter Eligibility (SAVE) Act. Republicans
EXCLUSIVECould you pay for a night out using just 2p pieces? MailOnline puts the power of pennies to the test – by buying pints, McDonald’s and a cab ride home with 27 bags of shrapnel (and the results might have you scrambling down the back of the sofa!)
Read More

EXCLUSIVECould you pay for a night out using just 2p pieces? MailOnline puts the power of pennies to the test – by buying pints, McDonald’s and a cab ride home with 27 bags of shrapnel (and the results might have you scrambling down the back of the sofa!)

'Just use your card man, this is a p***take'.  I'm in McDonalds in the heart of London's bustling West End attempting to pay for a single hamburger in 2 pence coins. The cost is £1.19, which equates to 60 two pence coins with one pence change.  'Hold on', I stammer as my fat fingers thumb

Trump leads Harris by 1 point: new national poll

Former President Donald Trump is leading Vice President Kamala Harris by one point nationally in the 2024 White House race, according to a new poll. The Fox News survey, released Wednesday, shows the ex-commander-in-chief leading the vice president 50% to 49% in a head-to-head race.  The results of the survey are the same as Fox