NYers use leaky hydrant to create ‘peaceful’ goldfish pond — but advocates call it animal abuse

There’s something fishy about this Brooklyn block. A puddle from a leaking hydrant has been turned into a public aquarium in Bedford-Stuyvesant, with dozens of goldfish swimming in an inch and a half of water at the bottom of a tree well — and a group of men standing guard. “It’s peaceful and tranquil, and

There’s something fishy about this Brooklyn block.

A puddle from a leaking hydrant has been turned into a public aquarium in Bedford-Stuyvesant, with dozens of goldfish swimming in an inch and a half of water at the bottom of a tree well — and a group of men standing guard.

“It’s peaceful and tranquil, and that’s the whole point,” said Je-Quan Irving, a driver for AAA, of the bizarre beautification effort. “We took it upon ourselves to spruce up this little area.”

Irving, 47, and others decided to buy the 30 or so feeder goldfish about a week ago, he said.

Je-Quan Irving, 47, at the community goldfish pond he and other men in Bed-Stuy set up around a leaking, decommissioned fire hydrant on Hancock Street. Helayne Seidman

The tiny orange and black fish could be seen Thursday swimming with cigarette butts, rusty beer bottle caps, AAA batteries, plastic costume pearls, rocks, pistachio shells, glass shards, the eraser end of a broken pencil, and lip gloss in a squeeze bottle.

The group of four men — friends who live in the neighborhood — plan to add snails and lights as well as a filtration system, he said.

In the fall, they’ll aim to remove the fish and hand them out to neighborhood children, he said. In the spring, they’ll introduce new fish back to the puddle on Hancock Street near Tompkins Avenue, which they plan on widening.

“It’s a work in progress,” he said, beaming.

Irving, who stands guard over the fish with the other men, set up security cameras to monitor the puddle.

People have tried to feed the fish rice, broccoli and tomato chunks. Helayne Seidman

“People try to steal them,” he said.

“Come talk to us. People think we’re doing harmful things to the fish. No, we feed them three times a day. We’re doing research on portable filters, because we want to appeal to the masses. We don’t want anyone thinking we’re doing any harm or foul here.”

But at least one animal advocate was flipping over the goldfish’s grim conditions.

Records from 311 show at least three complaints have been filed about the puddle within the last week.

Lenox Benoit, 4, stops by to check in on the fish. Helayne Seidman

On social media, neighborhood residents have posted footage of the fish, calling on people to contact 311 to gripe about the leaking hydrant.

“He thinks of this as some sort of community beautification project, which I could totally get behind but just not like this,” the person behind the online campaign told The Post.

The concerned citizen, who uses the Reddit handle Plantsnotpants, refused to give their name.

“I tried to tell him these aren’t humane conditions and offered him a five-gallon tank to house them in until he could get a proper habitat but he wasn’t interested,” the critic said, claiming they’ve taken 36 of the fish, under cover of night.

Irving said the goldfish are being humanely treated, but others disagree and have been rescuing the fish in the dead of night. Helayne Seidman

“He’ll undoubtedly tell you that we are ‘stealing’ his fish but if he just gets them adequate housing and a sustainable water source — not a leaking fire hydrant — we wouldn’t have to.”

“Ultimately I find the whole situation tragic,” the person added. “This guy and I have the same dream, to one day have a fish pond and to make our community better. Still, this is animal abuse happening openly on the street in the neighborhood I live in. It’s hard to ignore or excuse.”

While goldfish are resilient, they’re not bettas, which live in muddy puddles in Southeast Asia. Goldfish need treated, clean water, that’s frequently changed in order to survive.

The city’s Department of Environmental Protection was first made aware of the impromptu pond on Thursday, and DEP crews have been out to shut the hydrant “several times now,” a source explained, adding the hydrant is opened again after they leave.

The men behind the sidewalk pond have also been asked to remove the fish, with DEP workers informing them “it’s not a suitable or safe location for them,” the DEP official said.

“It’s imperative that our DEP operations team be allowed to fix the hydrant,” said Beth DeFalco, the DEP’s Deputy Commissioner for Public Affairs and Communications. “There are real safety concerns with damaged or leaking hydrants; it can impact the availability of water for fire emergencies, and it can impact water pressure and cause supply issues for the neighborhood. We love goldfish also, but we know there is a better home for them than on a sidewalk.”

Total
0
Shares
Leave a Reply
Related Posts
Hamas says leader killed in Israel strike in Iran
Read More

Hamas says leader killed in Israel strike in Iran

Hamas said Wednesday its political leader, Ismail Haniyeh, was killed in an Israeli strike in Iran, where he had been attending the inauguration of the country’s new president. Haniyeh’s killing came after Israel on Tuesday struck a Hezbollah stronghold in southern Beirut, killing a senior commander of the Iran-backed group it said was responsible for
First-place Astros make AL history with winning mark at ColiseumFirst-place Astros make AL history with winning mark at Coliseum
Read More

First-place Astros make AL history with winning mark at ColiseumFirst-place Astros make AL history with winning mark at Coliseum

First-place Astros make AL history with winning mark at Coliseum Altuve, Bregman complete their offensive dominance in Oakland's ballpark during finale rout July 24th, 2024 Sonja Chen @sonjamchen Share share-square-396678 OAKLAND -- When the Astros took two of three from the Mariners last weekend to move into a virtual tie for first place in the
Paris Olympics: Furious young Aussie says what most wouldn’t dare about opening ceremony stunt that mocked one of the West’s most sacred images
Read More

Paris Olympics: Furious young Aussie says what most wouldn’t dare about opening ceremony stunt that mocked one of the West’s most sacred images

A young Australian has hit out at the 2024 Paris Olympics opening ceremony, declaring it disrespected 2.4 billion Christians and was a 'sign the West has fallen'. Journalist and entrepreneur Carla Efstratiou took aim at a part of the ceremony which showed what appeared to be a nod to the iconic Leonardo da Vinci painting
Flashback: Harris tried to defund Border Patrol agents, slash ICE budget
Read More

Flashback: Harris tried to defund Border Patrol agents, slash ICE budget

close Video Presidential race appears to be tightening since Biden's withdrawal and ascension of Kamala Harris. Fox News senior White House correspondent Jacqui Heinrich has more on new presidential polling and potential debates between Trump and Harris on Special Report. Then-Sen. Kamala Harris, in 2018, pushed her colleagues in the Senate to reject a request